Why Aren’t Intranets more like Internets
March 30th, 2009by Jeremy Thomas
1994: WebCrawler and Lycos became the first widely adopted search engines. They flattened the Internet giving all resources an equal chance of being discovered. Before search engines, people were meant to find content by going to “what’s new” web pages where they’d find hyperlinks to web pages that had been recently added. From those pages they’d find links to other pages and so on. The Internet, at least at its conception, was meant to be surfed from site to site, not flattened. But search engines proved there was a much more efficient, comprehensive way to find information.
And I continue, bewildered, that companies follow the pre-Lycos model when constructing their intranets. For some reason they always try to consolidate information into knowledge management “silos” like Documentum. They set policies that change the homepage of their worker’s browsers to be the landing page for the new intranet portal which has “everything an employee will ever need to know” buried deep within. And then they wonder why nobody uses these new solutions.
It’s because they can’t find anything.
Data will always be federated, scattered across many information systems, just as it is on the Internet. Instead of investing in building a one size fits all intranet, invest in procuring and deploying an enterprise search engine. Let it crawl the file share. Let it crawl Lotus Notes. Let it crawl the shiny new Documentum application. Then set policies changing the worker’s homepage to the new enterprise search application if you must. And make that search page simple. Nobody understands taxonomies nor will they spend the time to. Forget faceting. Follow Google’s example making search dead simple. See what happens then. A search for “jury duty” might actually produce a result that tells the worker how much compensation he’s entitled to if summoned.
And I’ll bet your workers will be much less pissed off that you changed their browser’s default homepage.
Follow Me on Twitter
Co-Author
April 1st, 2009 at 9:48 am
It’s because they are built by the HR department who are intimately familiar with the information and how they (the HR team) have it organized.
April 11th, 2009 at 5:31 pm
I agree that organizations need a search engine that spans all enterprise applications.
However, search is not enough. You can only search things that you know exist. But what about things that you don’t know about? What about the latest updates from your team space? Or how do you find out more about an expert in your organization that you didn’t even know existed?
So, I think there is information that can be searched because we know about (or at least know that it should be somewhere) and information that needs to be presented to us based on our profile, geography, department, team etc. An Intranet homepage should combine search, mandatory information pushed by internal comms and information that is served to us depending on who we are.
April 15th, 2009 at 7:35 pm
A lot of times I find that the workers totally support having access to all the information within an organisation, but it’s the department heads that will want to hoard on information within their own space.
Take a look at any web sites run by state or federal governments, you can see how the boundaries of departments are drawn across their sites.
Maybe there is a need for ‘controlled’ autonomy, (is there such thing